Marketing by Raj

Google to CMOs: Stop Generic 'Top 10' Posts, Show Real Expertise

Google's Think with Google account told CMOs that content, not AI, makes brands invisible in Search. The advice targets generic tips posts, not every listicle, and it leans on first-hand expertise and business metrics.

Rajesh Kumar · 22 Nov 2026 · 3 min read

Google to CMOs: Stop Generic 'Top 10' Posts, Show Real Expertise
Key takeaways
  • Google's Think with Google account said on Nov. 19 that content, not AI, makes brands invisible in Search.
  • The linked Oct. 14 article by Brendon Kraham targets generic 'Top 10 Things to Consider' posts, not every listicle.
  • Google Search's May AI guide draws the same line, citing '7 Tips for First-Time Homebuyers' as commodity content.
  • Neither Google document addresses self-promotional 'best' lists.
  • Kraham advises planning around leads or sales, not unproven proxy metrics.

What happened

On Nov. 19, Google's Think with Google account posted a blunt line aimed at CMOs: "AI didn't make your brand invisible in Search. Your content did." The post paired "Stop the 'Top 10' listicle" with "start leading with first-hand expertise."

That first half set off questions among SEOs on X. Was Google telling brands to abandon listicles altogether? According to Search Engine Journal, the answer is more limited. The post links to an Oct. 14 article by Brendon Kraham, Google's VP of Search & Commerce Global Ads Solutions, and the example there is specific: a generic "Top 10 Things to Consider" post.

Kraham's example is a running store. Rather than publish that generic list, the store could make a deep-dive video analysing exactly why a particular customer's running shoes collapsed. His point is that this is advice nobody else could have written, because it comes from real-world experience.

What the article actually asks for

Kraham organises the piece around three CMO priorities: the "super-empowered consumer," building authority in your area of expertise, and producing measurable business results. On measurement, he says to plan around real goals like leads or sales, not "unproven proxy metrics."

Google Search's own guide to generative AI features, published in May, makes the same distinction. It uses "7 Tips for First-Time Homebuyers" as an example of commodity content, often based on common knowledge, and contrasts it with a first-hand piece about waiving a home inspection.

Notably, neither document mentions self-promotional "best" lists, where a company ranks itself number one. That is a separate issue. Lily Ray, who tracks that tactic, reported in June that many Google AI Overview results cited such listicles.

Why it matters

The headline reads like a ban on a format. The source material reads like a warning about sameness. A post that restates common knowledge gives search engines and AI systems no reason to pick your brand over anyone else's.

That matters for both classic search and AI answers. If ten sites publish the same checklist, an AI summary can blend them without needing you. A post that contains something only you could know is harder to replace.

There is also a messaging problem. Reaction on X was sceptical, with growth advisor Eli Schwartz giving a blunter version of the three steps, including "AEO VISIBILITY IS NOT REAL" next to the proxy-metrics line. Ross Hudgens of Siege Media replied that Google did not mean the type of listicle Ray was thinking of. Reasonable people read the same post differently, so treat it as direction, not policy.

What to do now

Audit your tips posts. Go through each one and ask whether it reflects something you learned first-hand or simply restates common knowledge. That is the test both Google documents apply.

Rewrite or retire the generic ones. Where you have real experience, add it: customer cases, product failures, testing results, photos or video of the actual work.

Use your operational data. A store sees returns, complaints, fit problems and repeat purchases. That is raw material competitors do not have, and it is the ecommerce version of the running shoe example.

Do not confuse this with the self-ranking issue. If you publish "best" lists, be honest about your own position and criteria. Google's documents do not address them, so do not read permission or prohibition into the post.

Judge content by leads and sales. Kraham's advice is to avoid unproven proxy metrics. Tie each content project to enquiries, conversions or revenue, not just visibility scores.

Watch the source. Google posts major Search documentation changes on its documentation updates page, which has an RSS feed.

Bottom line

Google is not outlawing lists. It is saying that interchangeable content will not carry a brand, in search or in AI answers. Specific, experience-led material is the safer investment.

Raj's take

The 'stop the Top 10' headline is clickbait for a sensible point: if anyone could have written your post, it will not win. I would audit every tips article this month and keep only what carries first-hand evidence from your own customers, products or tests. Do not read it as a verdict on all listicles, because Google's own documents do not say that.

Get the Daily Signal: AI, SEO and social media news in five minutes.

Want this applied to your business?

Free, no login: SEO, speed and AI-visibility score in about 60 seconds. One audit per email.

Related

Why Real Experts Beat SEO Loopholes in the AI Search Era
SEO·22 Nov 2026·3 min

Why Real Experts Beat SEO Loopholes in the AI Search Era

Lily Ray argues that every SEO shortcut eventually expires, while investing in real, identifiable people has held up through each cycle. Her case rests on 20+ years of consistent Google guidance and the E-E-A-T framework.