Marketing by Raj

A Rescue Dog Beat Amazon: What PPC Teams Should Do Now

A UK charity film about a boy and a rescue terrier topped DAIVID's ranking of 75 Christmas ads, ahead of Amazon. For PPC managers, the lesson is that emotion is now the scarce input in Performance Max and Demand Gen.

Rajesh Kumar · 22 Nov 2026 · 3 min read

A Rescue Dog Beat Amazon: What PPC Teams Should Do Now
Key takeaways
  • Dogs Trust's rescue-dog film topped DAIVID's ranking of 75 UK Christmas ads at 58.4%, ahead of Amazon at 55.2%.
  • The scores are AI predictions, and gaps below the top three are under 1 point, so use the chart as a brief, not a verdict.
  • With Gemini generating 1.5 billion assets, creative volume is cheap and emotional resonance is the scarce input.
  • Add one advertiser-made story video to Performance Max and Demand Gen, and run a controlled story-versus-offer test.
  • Track branded search volume and impression share as the bridge metric for brand-style creative.

What happened

DAIVID, an ad-testing firm, ranked 75 UK Christmas ads on Nov. 16. The winner was a 60-second charity film from Dogs Trust, "Kira Needs A Happy Place," about a boy and a scruffy rescue terrier. It is predicted to trigger intense positive emotions in 58.4% of viewers. Amazon's "Joy Delivered" came second at 55.2%, and Not On The High Street's "The Birdhouse" third at 54.0%.

The column in Search Engine Journal by Greg Jarboe uses the chart as a creative pretest for US advertisers heading into Cyber Week.

Why a UK ad chart matters to a Google Ads account

The money explains it. In Alphabet's Q3 2026 results, YouTube ads brought in $11.21 billion of $82.01 billion in Google advertising revenue, about 13.7%. That share has stayed between 12.8% and 13.8% over the last four quarters. Google's CFO said YouTube revenue rose 9%, with Brand the largest contributor.

Then there is the supply side. Google's Chief Business Officer said Gemini helped advertisers generate over 1.5 billion campaign assets, up more than 7x year over year. When anyone can produce a thousand headlines and video cuts, volume stops being an edge. An asset that actually moves people is what stays scarce.

Read the data with caution

These scores are predictions. DAIVID's AI models, trained on human responses to ads, forecast how viewers would feel. Nobody sat a fresh panel in front of the film, and the claim of performance improvements above 20% is the vendor's own.

The gaps are also small. Dogs Trust leads Amazon by 3.2 points, and places four through joint 10th sit within 0.9 points of each other. Last year's winner scored 58.2%, so even the best Christmas storytelling leaves about four in ten viewers short of intense positive emotion.

So treat the chart as a creative brief, not a leaderboard. The winners share a simple story, a character to root for, little product on screen until late, and emotions like hope, gratitude and trust that a discount banner can't create.

What to do before Cyber Week

Audit your asset groups. Check the video assets in Performance Max and Demand Gen. If you uploaded no video, the system builds one from your images and text, and it usually looks like it. Add at least one advertiser-made 15- or 30-second cut that tells a small human story before showing a product. Also review what Gemini generated for you, since default output tends to drift toward the same product-on-white look.

Test story against offer. Run a Demand Gen A/B experiment, emotional cut versus standard offer-led creative, with identical audiences, bidding and budgets. Ten days won't settle it, so run it through the December shipping deadlines and read conversion volume alongside cost per conversion.

Track branded search. Record branded query volume, branded impression share and branded conversions before the story asset goes live, then check weekly. If you meet spend thresholds, a Brand Lift study with search lift gives Google's read, which you should compare with your own branded campaign data.

Reuse what worked. The column notes Amazon reran its 2023 film "Joy Ride" as its 2025 hero ad after it tested strongly, and moved the production savings into media. If you have a past holiday video that performed, put it back in rather than rushing a weaker new one.

The bigger point

Bids, keywords and landing pages are increasingly automated, and Google fills accounts with generated creative. What a PPC manager still controls is whether the creative makes anyone care.

Raj's take

I like the argument, but I would not over-read a vendor's predicted scores. The takeaway is simpler: when every account gets the same AI-generated product-on-white assets, a small human story is a cheap way to stand out. Test it with a clean control and measure branded search, not just last-click ROAS.

Get the Daily Signal: AI, SEO and social media news in five minutes.

Want this applied to your business?

Free, no login: SEO, speed and AI-visibility score in about 60 seconds. One audit per email.

Related